Do white or yellow onions make you cry?
I'll answer
Earn 20 gold coins for an accepted answer.20
Earn 20 gold coins for an accepted answer.
40more
40more
Ethan Davis
Works at the International Labour Organization, Lives in Geneva, Switzerland.
As a culinary expert with a deep understanding of the chemistry behind our favorite foods, I can certainly shed some light on why certain onions might make us shed tears while others don't. The process is quite fascinating and involves a complex interaction of the onion's cellular structure and our own sensory response.
When we cut into an onion, we're essentially damaging its cells. This damage triggers a chemical reaction that releases a gas called syn-propanethial-S-oxide. This gas is a byproduct of the onion's natural defense mechanism against pests and is also the culprit behind our watery eyes. The gas is volatile and quickly evaporates, coming into contact with the moisture in our eyes and causing an irritation that our body interprets as a mild threat, hence the production of tears to flush out the irritant.
Now, the type of onion can indeed affect the intensity of this reaction. Yellow onions are known to be more pungent and are often used in cooking for their robust flavor. They contain a higher concentration of the enzymes that are responsible for the production of syn-propanethial-S-oxide. This is why they are often considered the "biggest culprits" when it comes to making us cry.
On the other hand, sweet onions like the Vidalia variety are bred to have a lower sulfur content, which directly affects the production of the tear-inducing gas. They are indeed milder and less likely to trigger the same strong reaction as their more pungent counterparts. Vidalia onions are popular in the southern United States and are known for their sweetness and lack of pungency, making them a favorite for raw dishes and salads where the crying factor is a definite disadvantage.
It's also worth noting that the environment in which onions are stored can influence their pungency. Onions stored in warmer temperatures will have a higher likelihood of making us cry due to the increased rate of enzymatic reactions. Conversely, refrigeration can slow down these reactions, but it can also affect the flavor and texture of the onion, making it less desirable for cooking.
In addition to the type and storage of the onion, the way we cut them can also play a role. Using a very sharp knife to make quick, clean cuts can minimize the cell damage and thus reduce the release of the gas. Similarly, cutting the root end off last can help to contain the gas, as this is where the highest concentration of enzymes is located.
Lastly, there are a few tricks that chefs and home cooks alike use to minimize the tearing effect. Some people find that chewing gum, breathing through the mouth, or even putting a piece of bread in the mouth can help to absorb the gas and reduce the irritation. Others swear by the use of food-grade carbon filters, which can absorb the gas before it reaches the eyes.
In conclusion, while all onions have the potential to make us cry due to their unique sulfur compounds, it's the yellow onions that are most likely to elicit this response due to their higher enzyme content. Sweet onions, like Vidalias, are a more pleasant alternative for those who wish to avoid the tears. And with a bit of knowledge and a few tricks up our sleeves, we can enjoy the benefits of onions in our cooking without the accompanying waterworks.
When we cut into an onion, we're essentially damaging its cells. This damage triggers a chemical reaction that releases a gas called syn-propanethial-S-oxide. This gas is a byproduct of the onion's natural defense mechanism against pests and is also the culprit behind our watery eyes. The gas is volatile and quickly evaporates, coming into contact with the moisture in our eyes and causing an irritation that our body interprets as a mild threat, hence the production of tears to flush out the irritant.
Now, the type of onion can indeed affect the intensity of this reaction. Yellow onions are known to be more pungent and are often used in cooking for their robust flavor. They contain a higher concentration of the enzymes that are responsible for the production of syn-propanethial-S-oxide. This is why they are often considered the "biggest culprits" when it comes to making us cry.
On the other hand, sweet onions like the Vidalia variety are bred to have a lower sulfur content, which directly affects the production of the tear-inducing gas. They are indeed milder and less likely to trigger the same strong reaction as their more pungent counterparts. Vidalia onions are popular in the southern United States and are known for their sweetness and lack of pungency, making them a favorite for raw dishes and salads where the crying factor is a definite disadvantage.
It's also worth noting that the environment in which onions are stored can influence their pungency. Onions stored in warmer temperatures will have a higher likelihood of making us cry due to the increased rate of enzymatic reactions. Conversely, refrigeration can slow down these reactions, but it can also affect the flavor and texture of the onion, making it less desirable for cooking.
In addition to the type and storage of the onion, the way we cut them can also play a role. Using a very sharp knife to make quick, clean cuts can minimize the cell damage and thus reduce the release of the gas. Similarly, cutting the root end off last can help to contain the gas, as this is where the highest concentration of enzymes is located.
Lastly, there are a few tricks that chefs and home cooks alike use to minimize the tearing effect. Some people find that chewing gum, breathing through the mouth, or even putting a piece of bread in the mouth can help to absorb the gas and reduce the irritation. Others swear by the use of food-grade carbon filters, which can absorb the gas before it reaches the eyes.
In conclusion, while all onions have the potential to make us cry due to their unique sulfur compounds, it's the yellow onions that are most likely to elicit this response due to their higher enzyme content. Sweet onions, like Vidalias, are a more pleasant alternative for those who wish to avoid the tears. And with a bit of knowledge and a few tricks up our sleeves, we can enjoy the benefits of onions in our cooking without the accompanying waterworks.
2024-04-29 20:24:09
reply(1)
Helpful(1122)
Helpful
Helpful(2)
Works at the International Seabed Authority, Lives in Kingston, Jamaica.
That means that yellow onions popular in cooking are the biggest culprits, and sweet, mild Vidalia onions are the least likely to trigger tears. Luckily, onions are the only type of vegetable that cause this crying reaction, because of their unique sulfur compounds.Sep 21, 2011
2023-06-25 08:33:53
Ethan Brown
QuesHub.com delivers expert answers and knowledge to you.
That means that yellow onions popular in cooking are the biggest culprits, and sweet, mild Vidalia onions are the least likely to trigger tears. Luckily, onions are the only type of vegetable that cause this crying reaction, because of their unique sulfur compounds.Sep 21, 2011
