What do the Scottish wear under their kilts 2024?

As a cultural expert with a keen interest in the traditions and customs of various societies, I often find myself delving into the intricacies of what might seem like simple questions, but actually carry a wealth of historical and cultural significance. The question of what Scottish people wear under their kilts is one such example. It's a topic that has been the subject of much debate and speculation, often clouded by stereotypes and misconceptions. Let's explore this subject with a touch of historical context and cultural sensitivity.
Step 1: English Answer
The kilt, a traditional garment of the Scottish people, has a rich history that dates back to the 16th century. It is a garment that is not only steeped in history but also in practicality, being designed for the rugged Scottish terrain and climate. The kilt is a type of tartan skirt, with the tartan pattern being a significant aspect of Scottish identity, representing different clans and families.
When it comes to what is worn under a kilt, there are a few different perspectives to consider. Traditionally, kilts were worn without any undergarments. This practice is rooted in both practicality and tradition. The absence of underwear allowed for greater freedom of movement and was more conducive to the damp and cold climate of Scotland, where the kilt was originally worn for work and battle.
The notion that Scottish men did not wear underwear under their kilts is further supported by historical accounts from military traditions. During the First World War, it is said that some Sergeant Majors used mirrors tied to the end of golf clubs to check under the kilts during inspections. This anecdote, while perhaps apocryphal, has become a part of the folklore surrounding kilt-wearing practices.
However, times have changed, and so have practices. Modern sensibilities, comfort, and hygiene have led many individuals who wear kilts to opt for wearing underwear. This choice is not only a matter of personal preference but also a reflection of evolving societal norms. Underwear can provide additional comfort and protection, especially in formal settings or during prolonged periods of wear.
Moreover, the decision to wear underwear under a kilt can also be influenced by the specific tartan pattern of the kilt. Some kilts are made from lighter, more delicate fabrics that might require the added protection of undergarments to prevent wear and tear.
It's also worth noting that the kilt is not just a garment but a symbol of Scottish heritage and pride. The way it is worn, including whether or not it is worn with underwear, is a personal choice that can be influenced by a variety of factors, including personal comfort, the occasion, and cultural or family traditions.
In conclusion, while the traditional practice was to wear a kilt without undergarments, the modern trend leans towards wearing underwear for reasons of comfort, hygiene, and practicality. The choice is ultimately up to the individual, and it is important to respect the personal decisions of those who choose to wear kilts, with or without underwear, as part of their cultural expression.
**

Not wearing underwear under a kilt is a Scottish military tradition. During the First World War, some Sergeant Majors reportedly used mirrors tied to the end of golf clubs to look up and under the kilt during inspections. ... "I think true Scots who like to wear kilts a lot will wear underwear, it's just more hygienic.Feb 15, 2009