Which confidence interval is more accurate?
I'll answer
Earn 20 gold coins for an accepted answer.20
Earn 20 gold coins for an accepted answer.
40more
40more
Oliver Hall
Works at the United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime, Lives in Vienna, Austria.
As a domain expert in statistics, I would like to clarify a common misconception regarding the concept of confidence intervals and their accuracy.
Confidence intervals are a fundamental tool in inferential statistics that provide an estimated range of values which are likely to contain an unknown population parameter. The accuracy of a confidence interval is not determined by its width, but rather by the correct coverage of the true population parameter.
**Step 1: Understanding Confidence Intervals**
A confidence interval is constructed around a sample statistic (such as the sample mean) to infer the population parameter. The level of confidence, often denoted as (1 - α), represents the proportion of possible confidence intervals that will contain the true parameter if the experiment were repeated an infinite number of times. For example, a 95% confidence interval suggests that if we were to take many samples and construct a confidence interval from each, 95% of those intervals would contain the true population mean.
The Width of Confidence Intervals
The width of a confidence interval is influenced by several factors:
1. Sample Size (n): Larger sample sizes typically lead to narrower intervals because they provide more information about the population.
2. Population Standard Deviation (σ): A larger population standard deviation results in wider intervals.
3. Confidence Level: A higher confidence level (e.g., 99% vs. 95%) generally results in a wider interval to account for the increased probability of capturing the true parameter.
Accuracy and Precision
The statement that a narrow interval implies higher accuracy is not entirely accurate. While a narrow interval may suggest greater precision (closeness of the sample statistic to the population parameter), it does not necessarily mean greater accuracy (correctness of the parameter estimate). A confidence interval's accuracy is about whether it correctly includes the true parameter value, not how wide or narrow it is.
**The Misunderstanding About 95% vs. 99% Confidence Intervals**
The claim that a 99% confidence interval is more accurate than a 95% confidence interval is incorrect. Both intervals are constructed to include the true parameter with their respective levels of confidence. A 99% confidence interval is wider because it is designed to be more inclusive, not because it is more accurate. If the true parameter falls outside of a 95% confidence interval, it does not mean that the interval is inaccurate; it simply means that the interval has failed in that particular instance, which is expected to happen 5% of the time.
Step 2: Conclusion
In summary, the accuracy of a confidence interval is about its ability to cover the true population parameter the specified proportion of the time, not its width. A narrower interval does not guarantee greater accuracy, and a higher confidence level does not mean greater accuracy either—it simply means that the interval is constructed to be more inclusive.
**
Confidence intervals are a fundamental tool in inferential statistics that provide an estimated range of values which are likely to contain an unknown population parameter. The accuracy of a confidence interval is not determined by its width, but rather by the correct coverage of the true population parameter.
**Step 1: Understanding Confidence Intervals**
A confidence interval is constructed around a sample statistic (such as the sample mean) to infer the population parameter. The level of confidence, often denoted as (1 - α), represents the proportion of possible confidence intervals that will contain the true parameter if the experiment were repeated an infinite number of times. For example, a 95% confidence interval suggests that if we were to take many samples and construct a confidence interval from each, 95% of those intervals would contain the true population mean.
The Width of Confidence Intervals
The width of a confidence interval is influenced by several factors:
1. Sample Size (n): Larger sample sizes typically lead to narrower intervals because they provide more information about the population.
2. Population Standard Deviation (σ): A larger population standard deviation results in wider intervals.
3. Confidence Level: A higher confidence level (e.g., 99% vs. 95%) generally results in a wider interval to account for the increased probability of capturing the true parameter.
Accuracy and Precision
The statement that a narrow interval implies higher accuracy is not entirely accurate. While a narrow interval may suggest greater precision (closeness of the sample statistic to the population parameter), it does not necessarily mean greater accuracy (correctness of the parameter estimate). A confidence interval's accuracy is about whether it correctly includes the true parameter value, not how wide or narrow it is.
**The Misunderstanding About 95% vs. 99% Confidence Intervals**
The claim that a 99% confidence interval is more accurate than a 95% confidence interval is incorrect. Both intervals are constructed to include the true parameter with their respective levels of confidence. A 99% confidence interval is wider because it is designed to be more inclusive, not because it is more accurate. If the true parameter falls outside of a 95% confidence interval, it does not mean that the interval is inaccurate; it simply means that the interval has failed in that particular instance, which is expected to happen 5% of the time.
Step 2: Conclusion
In summary, the accuracy of a confidence interval is about its ability to cover the true population parameter the specified proportion of the time, not its width. A narrower interval does not guarantee greater accuracy, and a higher confidence level does not mean greater accuracy either—it simply means that the interval is constructed to be more inclusive.
**
2024-05-08 22:26:39
reply(1)
Helpful(1122)
Helpful
Helpful(2)
Studied at the University of Oxford, Lives in Oxford, UK.
Apparently a narrow confidence interval implies that there is a smaller chance of obtaining an observation within that interval, therefore, our accuracy is higher. Also a 95% confidence interval is narrower than a 99% confidence interval which is wider. The 99% confidence interval is more accurate than the 95%.Sep 28, 2011
2023-06-12 20:51:31
Ethan Patel
QuesHub.com delivers expert answers and knowledge to you.
Apparently a narrow confidence interval implies that there is a smaller chance of obtaining an observation within that interval, therefore, our accuracy is higher. Also a 95% confidence interval is narrower than a 99% confidence interval which is wider. The 99% confidence interval is more accurate than the 95%.Sep 28, 2011
