Are dissertations a scholarly source?
I'll answer
Earn 20 gold coins for an accepted answer.20
Earn 20 gold coins for an accepted answer.
40more
40more
Isabella Hall
Studied at the University of Seoul, Lives in Seoul, South Korea.
As an expert in the field of academic research and scholarly communication, I can provide a comprehensive understanding of whether dissertations are considered scholarly sources and how they differ from other forms of scholarly works such as articles.
Firstly, it is important to define what constitutes a scholarly source. Scholarly sources are typically characterized by their rigorous research, critical analysis, and adherence to academic standards. They are often peer-reviewed, meaning that other experts in the field have evaluated the work for quality and credibility before it is published. Scholarly sources are essential for academic and professional research because they provide reliable, in-depth, and authoritative information on a given subject.
Now, let's delve into the nature of dissertations. A dissertation is a lengthy, in-depth academic treatise that is usually required to be completed in order to obtain a doctoral degree, such as a Ph.D. It represents the culmination of years of research and is intended to contribute original knowledge or theory to the academic field. Dissertations are indeed scholarly works as they embody the principles of rigorous research, critical analysis, and academic integrity.
However, there are several distinctions between dissertations and articles that are worth noting:
1. Length: As mentioned in the provided content, dissertations are typically much longer than scholarly articles. While articles are often confined to a few pages to fit within the scope of a journal, dissertations can span hundreds of pages, allowing for a more comprehensive exploration of a topic.
2. Scope: Dissertations cover a broader range of topics and delve deeper into the subject matter. They often include extensive literature reviews, theoretical frameworks, methodological discussions, and detailed findings, which are beyond the scope of most scholarly articles.
3. Accessibility: Scholarly articles are widely accessible through academic journals and databases, making them more readily available to the academic community and the general public. Dissertations, on the other hand, may not be as easily accessible. While many universities are making efforts to digitize and share dissertations, they are not always as widely disseminated as articles.
4. Peer Review: Scholarly articles undergo a rigorous peer-review process before publication, which ensures that the research meets the community's standards for quality and originality. Dissertations, while subject to review by a candidate's dissertation committee, do not typically go through the same level of external peer review as articles.
5. Citation Practices: In academic writing, the citation of scholarly sources is crucial. While dissertations are certainly cited, they are often cited with more caution due to their limited peer review and the fact that they represent a single researcher's work rather than a consensus within the field.
6. Evolution of Research: Dissertations are often seen as the starting point for a researcher's career, laying the groundwork for future research. Over time, the findings and theories presented in a dissertation may be refined, expanded upon, or even refuted as new research emerges. Articles, being more succinct and subject to peer review, are often seen as more current representations of a researcher's work.
7.
Recognition and Impact: The impact of a dissertation is typically measured by how it influences the field through subsequent research and publications. While a well-regarded dissertation can be highly influential, its recognition within the academic community may be more delayed compared to the immediate visibility that a published article can achieve.
In conclusion, dissertations are indeed scholarly sources, but they are distinct from scholarly articles in several important ways. They are comprehensive, original contributions to the academic discourse, but their length, scope, and review process set them apart from the more concise and peer-reviewed articles that are a staple of academic journals. Both types of works are valuable and play different roles in the scholarly ecosystem, and understanding these differences is key to effectively utilizing and appreciating each as a source of academic information.
Firstly, it is important to define what constitutes a scholarly source. Scholarly sources are typically characterized by their rigorous research, critical analysis, and adherence to academic standards. They are often peer-reviewed, meaning that other experts in the field have evaluated the work for quality and credibility before it is published. Scholarly sources are essential for academic and professional research because they provide reliable, in-depth, and authoritative information on a given subject.
Now, let's delve into the nature of dissertations. A dissertation is a lengthy, in-depth academic treatise that is usually required to be completed in order to obtain a doctoral degree, such as a Ph.D. It represents the culmination of years of research and is intended to contribute original knowledge or theory to the academic field. Dissertations are indeed scholarly works as they embody the principles of rigorous research, critical analysis, and academic integrity.
However, there are several distinctions between dissertations and articles that are worth noting:
1. Length: As mentioned in the provided content, dissertations are typically much longer than scholarly articles. While articles are often confined to a few pages to fit within the scope of a journal, dissertations can span hundreds of pages, allowing for a more comprehensive exploration of a topic.
2. Scope: Dissertations cover a broader range of topics and delve deeper into the subject matter. They often include extensive literature reviews, theoretical frameworks, methodological discussions, and detailed findings, which are beyond the scope of most scholarly articles.
3. Accessibility: Scholarly articles are widely accessible through academic journals and databases, making them more readily available to the academic community and the general public. Dissertations, on the other hand, may not be as easily accessible. While many universities are making efforts to digitize and share dissertations, they are not always as widely disseminated as articles.
4. Peer Review: Scholarly articles undergo a rigorous peer-review process before publication, which ensures that the research meets the community's standards for quality and originality. Dissertations, while subject to review by a candidate's dissertation committee, do not typically go through the same level of external peer review as articles.
5. Citation Practices: In academic writing, the citation of scholarly sources is crucial. While dissertations are certainly cited, they are often cited with more caution due to their limited peer review and the fact that they represent a single researcher's work rather than a consensus within the field.
6. Evolution of Research: Dissertations are often seen as the starting point for a researcher's career, laying the groundwork for future research. Over time, the findings and theories presented in a dissertation may be refined, expanded upon, or even refuted as new research emerges. Articles, being more succinct and subject to peer review, are often seen as more current representations of a researcher's work.
7.
Recognition and Impact: The impact of a dissertation is typically measured by how it influences the field through subsequent research and publications. While a well-regarded dissertation can be highly influential, its recognition within the academic community may be more delayed compared to the immediate visibility that a published article can achieve.
In conclusion, dissertations are indeed scholarly sources, but they are distinct from scholarly articles in several important ways. They are comprehensive, original contributions to the academic discourse, but their length, scope, and review process set them apart from the more concise and peer-reviewed articles that are a staple of academic journals. Both types of works are valuable and play different roles in the scholarly ecosystem, and understanding these differences is key to effectively utilizing and appreciating each as a source of academic information.
2024-05-12 03:10:31
reply(1)
Helpful(1122)
Helpful
Helpful(2)
Studied at the University of Cambridge, Lives in Cambridge, UK.
A college dissertation would be considered a scholarly work, but a dissertation is different from an article in ways that may be important to you. A dissertation is usually the length of a book, perhaps 100 pages or more. Scholarly articles are usually much shorter than that.Oct 30, 2014
2023-06-11 08:18:32
Sophia Harris
QuesHub.com delivers expert answers and knowledge to you.
A college dissertation would be considered a scholarly work, but a dissertation is different from an article in ways that may be important to you. A dissertation is usually the length of a book, perhaps 100 pages or more. Scholarly articles are usually much shorter than that.Oct 30, 2014
