What is a good argument 2024?
I'll answer
Earn 20 gold coins for an accepted answer.20
Earn 20 gold coins for an accepted answer.
40more
40more
Amelia Sanchez
Studied at the University of Vienna, Lives in Vienna, Austria.
As a seasoned expert in the field of logic and critical thinking, I am well-versed in the nuances of constructing and evaluating arguments. Let's delve into what constitutes a good argument.
A good argument is a persuasive and logical sequence of statements that aims to establish a conclusion based on premises that are both true and relevant. It is a tool for reasoning and communication that can be used in various contexts, from academic debates to everyday discussions. Here are some key characteristics of a good argument:
1. Clarity: The argument should be clear and easily understood. Ambiguity can lead to misinterpretation and weaken the argument.
2. Relevance: Each premise should be directly related to the conclusion. Irrelevant information, while it may be interesting, does not contribute to the argument's strength.
3. Coherence: The argument must be logically coherent. The premises should logically lead to the conclusion without any logical leaps or inconsistencies.
4. Soundness: A sound argument is both valid and has all true premises. Validity means that the conclusion follows necessarily from the premises, while having true premises ensures that the argument is not based on falsehoods.
5. Strength: A strong argument has premises that provide compelling support for the conclusion. The more strongly the premises support the conclusion, the stronger the argument.
6. Plausibility: The premises should be plausible, meaning they are believable and can be accepted by a reasonable person. They should not be controversial or disputed without good reason.
7.
Non-question-begging: The premises should not assume the truth of the conclusion. An argument that begs the question is circular and does not provide any actual support for the conclusion.
8.
Evidence: Ideally, the premises should be supported by evidence. Evidence can come in many forms, including empirical data, expert testimony, and logical deductions.
Now, let's address the claims mentioned and explain why they might be mistaken:
- Validity: While validity is important, it is not the only criterion for a good argument. An argument can be valid but still be poor if the premises are not true or relevant.
- True Premises: True premises are essential, but truth alone does not make an argument good. The premises must also be relevant and provide actual support for the conclusion.
- Non-question-begging: This is a crucial point. An argument that begs the question is not actually providing new support for the conclusion but is merely reiterating it in different words.
- Relevance: Relevance is often overlooked, but it is fundamental. Even if the premises are true and the argument is valid, if they do not relate to the conclusion, the argument fails to persuade.
In summary, a good argument is a complex interplay of clarity, relevance, coherence, soundness, strength, plausibility, and evidence. It is more than just being valid or having true premises; it is about constructing a persuasive and logically sound case that leads to a well-supported conclusion.
A good argument is a persuasive and logical sequence of statements that aims to establish a conclusion based on premises that are both true and relevant. It is a tool for reasoning and communication that can be used in various contexts, from academic debates to everyday discussions. Here are some key characteristics of a good argument:
1. Clarity: The argument should be clear and easily understood. Ambiguity can lead to misinterpretation and weaken the argument.
2. Relevance: Each premise should be directly related to the conclusion. Irrelevant information, while it may be interesting, does not contribute to the argument's strength.
3. Coherence: The argument must be logically coherent. The premises should logically lead to the conclusion without any logical leaps or inconsistencies.
4. Soundness: A sound argument is both valid and has all true premises. Validity means that the conclusion follows necessarily from the premises, while having true premises ensures that the argument is not based on falsehoods.
5. Strength: A strong argument has premises that provide compelling support for the conclusion. The more strongly the premises support the conclusion, the stronger the argument.
6. Plausibility: The premises should be plausible, meaning they are believable and can be accepted by a reasonable person. They should not be controversial or disputed without good reason.
7.
Non-question-begging: The premises should not assume the truth of the conclusion. An argument that begs the question is circular and does not provide any actual support for the conclusion.
8.
Evidence: Ideally, the premises should be supported by evidence. Evidence can come in many forms, including empirical data, expert testimony, and logical deductions.
Now, let's address the claims mentioned and explain why they might be mistaken:
- Validity: While validity is important, it is not the only criterion for a good argument. An argument can be valid but still be poor if the premises are not true or relevant.
- True Premises: True premises are essential, but truth alone does not make an argument good. The premises must also be relevant and provide actual support for the conclusion.
- Non-question-begging: This is a crucial point. An argument that begs the question is not actually providing new support for the conclusion but is merely reiterating it in different words.
- Relevance: Relevance is often overlooked, but it is fundamental. Even if the premises are true and the argument is valid, if they do not relate to the conclusion, the argument fails to persuade.
In summary, a good argument is a complex interplay of clarity, relevance, coherence, soundness, strength, plausibility, and evidence. It is more than just being valid or having true premises; it is about constructing a persuasive and logically sound case that leads to a well-supported conclusion.
2024-06-16 17:22:23
reply(1)
Helpful(1122)
Helpful
Helpful(2)
Works at the International Olympic Committee, Lives in Lausanne, Switzerland.
A good argument is an argument that is either valid or strong, and with plausible premises that are true, do not beg the question, and are relevant to the conclusion. Now that you know what a good argument is, you should be able to explain why these claims are mistaken.
2023-06-19 05:18:28
Julian Hill
QuesHub.com delivers expert answers and knowledge to you.
A good argument is an argument that is either valid or strong, and with plausible premises that are true, do not beg the question, and are relevant to the conclusion. Now that you know what a good argument is, you should be able to explain why these claims are mistaken.
